Poison is one of the rarest murder weapons, and one of the hardest to prove. It leaves no wound and often no witness, and the symptoms can look like ordinary illness. Wisconsin has seen three cases in three counties that show how these crimes come to light: one solved by a dead woman’s letter and a home computer, one by an unusual toxicology test, and one, still unproven, that began with a victim who kept getting sick.

Kenosha County: the antifreeze case

Julie Jensen died in her Pleasant Prairie home in December 1998. Before her death she gave a neighbor a sealed letter and left voicemails for a police officer. They said that if she were found dead, her husband should be suspected.

Investigators found that ethylene glycol, the main ingredient in antifreeze, had played a role in her death. Mark Jensen was convicted of first-degree intentional homicide in 2008. A federal appeals court later overturned that verdict, ruling that Julie’s letter should not have been used because it violated his constitutional right to confront the witnesses against him.

Prosecutors tried him again without the letter. This time they relied heavily on the family’s home computer, which had recorded searches for ethylene glycol, poisons and related symptoms in the weeks before her death. A Kenosha County jury convicted Jensen a second time in February 2023, and he was sentenced in April 2023 to life in prison without parole. In September 2026 he filed a motion seeking a third trial, arguing his defense attorneys mishandled the computer evidence.

Waukesha County: the eye drops case

In October 2018, Lynn Hernan, 62, was found dead in her Pewaukee home. Her death was eventually traced to a lethal amount of tetrahydrozoline, the active ingredient in common over-the-counter eye drops like Visine, which does not show up on a standard toxicology screen.

Prosecutors said her friend, Jessy Kurczewski of Franklin, put the contents of several bottles of eye drops into Hernan’s water and left. They said Kurczewski had stolen close to $300,000 from Hernan and killed her to keep it from coming out. In November 2023 a jury found Kurczewski guilty of first-degree intentional homicide and felony theft. She was sentenced to life in prison, with eligibility for extended supervision only after 30 years.

Rock County: a case still in court

The third case is unproven, and the people charged are presumed innocent.

In June 2025, prosecutors charged Paul VanDuyne Jr. and Andrea Whitaker, both of Madison, in what they describe as a plot to poison women VanDuyne had previously dated, one in Dane County and one in Rock County. According to the criminal complaint, substances including cyanide and thallium were placed in a Rock County woman’s gym water bottle and in her car’s air vents. Prosecutors say she was hospitalized for weeks.

VanDuyne was arrested in the Town of Fulton in June 2025. Prosecutors say he was watching the Rock County woman’s home at the time. In Rock County he faces charges including three counts of attempted first-degree intentional homicide. Bond was set at $37.5 million. Whitaker is charged with attempted first-degree intentional homicide and with harboring or aiding a felon, and has pleaded not guilty. A Rock County trial is scheduled for March 2027.

What the cases have in common

In all three, the victim knew the person accused. In the two solved cases, the poison was something found in an ordinary home: antifreeze and eye drops. Both took a specific, deliberate lab test and years of work to prove in court. The Rock County case is still waiting for its day in court, and a jury, not the headlines, will decide it.

Sources: Murder of Julie Jensen; TMJ4; WISN; CBS News; FOX6; WMTV; Spectrum News; WMTV; FOX47.